i am 21 and i liked the second ring better.......i didn't like the first one.....white gold or silver is the in thing now....for me ( i am also not a real girly girl) i would like something like a band that i could wear on my thumb or my index finger.....from my mom......i would rather my boyfriend get me a ring for my ring finger......

just my opinion.........sorry if i am too late

no matter what you decide she is gonna like it because it is from her mom