yeah the only problem with that sue, is my idea is a more positive and it teaches the dog to have a better walk too so she dosn't have to buy another leash and collor cuz, that kind of stuff can get to be expensive. MY idea also teaches the dog to look up at you too, because when dogs pull it basiacally means there in control and when there no pulling it means the dog respects you. your dog ends up bonding more with you if you use treats too!