I posted a thread about 2 months ago about Wingaling. I feed my dog Fenway, Merrick dog food. I fed him the Wingaling with the bones and I thought he would chew them. But I noticed after 1 minute of putting the food down the bones were gone so I freaked out thinking he had bones in his tummy just sitting there. So I decided to no longer feed him Wingaling. But then someone on this board said the wings were soft and to test how soft they were. So I bought another can and sure enough, they were soft bones. So I continued to buy it. But after reading your thread, I don't think I will. However, I will continue to feed Fenway the other Merrick food. He eats a 1/2 part of Merrick dried food with a 1/2 part of Innova dry food. I also feed him Innova wet food sometimes. I always thought Merrick was a good company and the place that I purchase it raves about it. Fenway eats Grammy's Pot Pie dry food.