Here's my situation. I give my dog’s Chicken soup for the dog lovers Soul. I love this food. It makes their hair shiny and I love the ingredients. Plus they seem to like it. Here's the problem... Harley and Morty are trim, but Sylvia is over weight. All three eat about the same, but Harley eats the most and all three are pretty active, but Harley is the most active. I've heard other people say the Chicken Soup food makes their dogs’ fat. My dogs are used to free eating, meaning they almost always have food available within reason. If they eat all their food for one day I just don't give them more. Since their food is dry, it can stay out all day. They have never abused the system. No one dog, even Sylvia, just keeps eating.

Anyway, I'm considering changing their food so Sylvia can lose weight, but all three will be switched. I'm looking for a good, premium food with ingredients simple to the Chick soup food. Can anyone recommend anything? It doesn't necessarily have to be light food.