Oh Jenn! Poor pupper! And Collin, of course But I've been there Jenn. Went to kick the soccer ball for Star once and ended up kicking her It took me weeks to get the vision of her terrified face out of my head! A few times I've thrown the ball for her where she goes out for a pass, turns around and ends up getting beaned with the ball! She would cringe and crawl if I held up that yellow ball for weeks. I hope Duncan AND Collin are doing better, Jenn. But you're right, the grown man knows what happened and why; not the pup! I too would have definitely headed for the wounded pup, not the husband! Hugs to you beautiful, brave Duncan!