Here's the puzzle:

-hat -- -a- --th--t the -ea-t-?
-- a-- the -ea-t- -e-e ---e, -e- ----- --e ---- a --eat ---e---e-- --
-----t.
--- -hate-e- ha--e-- t- the -ea-t-, ---- ha--e-- t- -a-.
A-- th---- a-e ----e-te-.

-h-e- -eatt-e


Letters to choose from:

BCDFGIJKLMNOPQRSUVWXYZ

There are 18 T's
There are 24 E's
There are 10 H's
There are 15 A's

momoffuzzy faces has 18 points
sirocco has 48 points
AmberLee has 10 points
Karen has 30 points