American Idol Season 5

[CagneyDog]

Oh, yeah, I forgot to mention Mandisa.
She's probably my favorite out of all of them. She just seems so original and comfortable with being herself.

[RobiLee]

I'm disappointed that Melissa got kicked off. I like her personality and I like her voice. I can't believe that Kevin wasn't even in the bottom 3. I just can't believe that at this level others are leaving before him. I was shocked that Ace was in the bottom three. I had the feeling that every one liked him.

I have quite a few favorites and it is just going to kill me when one of them has to go. At this point I hate seeing any one get kicked off though. I just hate seeing the hurt on their faces. Although, I think I could handle it ok if it were to be Kevin next week...lol

[Lobodeb]

I have to agree with Robin. I liked Melissa and I loved her voice. Kevin should have gone long before her, but I knew she was a longshot. I totally disagree with the bottom 3. Lisa Tucker? That girl could sing the phone book. I think it was the arrangement of her song that I didn't like. How many times could she say, "signed sealed delivered?"

[rosethecopycat]

I think it was the arrangement of her song that I didn't like. How many times could she say, "signed sealed delivered?"

Exactly. That was a weak song. We were worried about her, and when she got called out, I thought my husband was going to be right, for once.

But, they crucified Melissa for breaking the cardinal rule, as I suspected.

[anna_66]

I have to say I'm very surprised about the bottom 3 and even more surprised that Melissa was the one who ended up leaving. I really loved her voice.

[beeniesmom]

I knew Melissa was going to go.... were you guys really that surprised?

I think Kevin is next and then Lisa.

I was not surprised to see Ace in the bottom 3.

Someone had to be there. It could have been anyone.

I think our top 3 are:

Chris
Katherine
Taylor

[pitc9]

I think our top 3 are:

Chris
Katherine
Taylor

I agree 100%!! Those are going to be the last three left in the end!!

[dogzr#1]

I was kinda surprised to see Lisa in the bottom three. I really like her. I don't like Ace at all. I don't know why but I just want him to go. He looks like a camera hog. Like he's there only for the camera. I like Kevin even though his voice isn't all that great. He is just so darn cute.

I love Chris. He has a really strong voice and he sounds really good.
My three favorite girls are: Paris, Lisa, and Mandisa.
My three favorite guys are: Chris, Elliot, and Taylor.

I am kinda glad that Melissa went home. I had guessed either her, Kevin or Bucky would go home.
Again surprised to see Lisa in the bottom three.

[AlleyCat]

I still say:

[Crazy-Cat-Lover]

I didn't really like Melissa, although she did have a great voice. I want to see Chris and Katherine fighting for the win.

[Dixieland Dancer]

I was surprised that Kevin wasn't in the bottom 3 but I had a strong feeling Melissa was the one going. I'm not an Ace fan but I was surprised he was in the bottom 3. Lisa definitely didn't deserve to be there.

All of the remaining contestants are very talented and I find myself enjoying all of there performances.

I believe of all the judges, Simon understands what is going on more than the others even though he is tactless.

[rosethecopycat]

I believe of all the judges, Simon understands what is going on more than the others even though he is tactless.

True enough.

[krazyaboutkatz]

I've really been enjoying watching AI this season. My favorite male performers are Chris and Taylor and my favorite female performers are Katherine and Mandisa. Ace does nothing for me and Kevin is cute but I don't think that he's got what it takes to win. I was shocked that Kevin wasn't in the bottom 3 and that Lisa was.

[*iluvskipper*]

lol yeah kellie pickler is good. i wanted this other guy to win i think his name was Bucky or something. oh well . . . . . .

[Felix]

Wow! Chris blew me away with his performance tonight,loved his version of "walk the line"...he sure Rocks My World! GO CHRIS GO!

Mandisa was HOT tonight,she looked great and sounded awsome.

Buckey did ok,upbeat.

Katharine's performance was terrific.

Taylor keeps me dancing in my seat,hes so energetic.I love his upbeat attitude. Got to love his moves "Complete mess" *Shakes head* Oh Simon get with it!

Kevin,well he should have been gone long ago.Sorry Kevin lovers,but I dont think he's got what it takes.All the girlies love him thou,hehehe.

Lisa performed ok,didn't WOW me thou.

Paris was awsome as usual,such a sweetie she is.

Ace was ok,Pretty boy is back.

Elliott got a certian something,I liked his performance.

I was never a fan of Pickler's,but I enjoyed her performance tonight.