I have two cats and one angry Fiance (haa haa). The sides of our loveseat has been demolished by our first cat, Amber. The Grey Cat (okay he has been "temporarily" with us for 11 months and neither of us have any intention of parting with him, but "identification" name stuck!) is rather good natured (I still wonder how anybody could kick him to the curb) and occasionally pulls the carpet to sharpen. He has recently dabbled in the couch, which I assume is due to trying to move in on Amber's turf. Though the counch is old and we cover it with slipcovers, we would like to purchase nicer couches after we graduate (a few years to come). Amber will scratch her carpeted house occassionally, but she really loves that right back corner on the couch. Her behavior leads me to believe that if given the right incentive, she would scratch a post religiously. The couch is made of this material that has ridges, and if I was a cat, I would scratch it too.
So here is the problem, until we get new couches, I will not know if I can transfer her over to a post (I am tempted to fashion one out of the couch pillows one day or saved that whole damned corner for her), and I do not want to risk the new couch getting damaged.
I reward my Australian Shepherd for barking at Amber when she claws (most amusing for both dog and owner) and somewhat effective when he is not in his crate or asleep.
Declawing is the LAST resort. I mean LAST. As in either the cats claws go or the cats go.
I have tried soft paws on both cats and they are effective. Expensive for college students, but effective. Grey Cat is indifferent. Amber gets a little freaked by them when she attempts to sharpen and gets no purchase on the couch. She tears around awhile which is amusing. Getting the Soft Paws on Amber is a bit of a challenge. She has asthma and situations which stress her cause her to have a mini astma attatck. For instance, when I grab her paw to clip her nails (putting on the soft paws is a two person job) she starts to wheeze. It carries on, only getting worse, and is very distressing to her and me (and the dog who adores her). The soft paw applicaition is a two person job. Amber has also had siezures in the past which are related to times of breathing trouble (from great stress) and I subsequently do not want to stress her more.
I am sickened by the thought of declawing (more so that If I declaw Amber, I have to declaw the non-guilty Grey Cat because they fight something nasty every now and then and it is not fair for one to have nails over the other). Yet, having to drive her into a asthma attack (and possibly a siezure) every time she needs maintainence on her claws really does not seem right either. Believe me, I have tried to reduce her stress. Having my fiance hold her by the scruff while I clip and glue is so sorry but immoblizing her with the help of a blanket or a kitty carrier stresses her so much one can feel her wheezes (and I am gentle as possible). I treat her like she is more glass than cat.
Bookmarks