*sigh* I am so tired of forum arguments. Maybe negativity was the wrong word but that was what I felt when I read the posts. Maybe the word I should have used was without such a condescending attitude? I might be splitting hairs or making mountains out of molehills but this is what I felt when I read these posts.
Quote:
Originally posted by PayItForward
You do realise after having a very tiny kitten for a few weeks, you have a cat for 19 long years !!!
I ask because if you knew anything about cats, you would know that cats are kittens until their second birthday. i.e. A six month old kitten is a little kitten.
Is there any reason for having a very young kitten ?
If you knew anything about cats??? Please...
Quote:
Originally posted by PayItForward
I have just read your profile, as you are expecting baby shortly and already have a dog.
I would suggest that you wait until your baby is older before you commit yourself to another pet.
Why are you automatically assuming that she has not though of the responsibilities that come with a baby and owning a pet? That she is not prepared or educated to deal with the situations and difficulties that might arise? And why not present some of those challenges that she might face that lead you to suggest that she wait until the baby is older? And how old should the baby be? I know many groups that will not adopt kittens to families with children under six. There are reasons behind this. Why not present some of these reasons to support your suggestion?
Quote:
Originally posted by PayItForward
This statement alone worries me. You might not have to walk a cat (well unless you live in the USA) but a cat takes up a lot of time.
But as you have made your mind up, I will not comment further. Good luck with your family.
That was made in response to the "Cats are fairly low maintence that's why we'd rather get one more than a dog." And it is true, when compared to dogs, cats are IMHO, lower maintanence than a dog. Why does this statement worry you? I got my first cat because I live in a townhouse and I did not have the room for a dog to run nor the time to walk it. And I am so glad because I realize how wonderful cats are.
Quote:
Originally posted by moosmom
I have to agree with PayItForward. When you adopt a kitten, you are in for a commitment of 19 years. Are you ready for that kind of commitment???
Once again automatically assuming that she has no idea cats.
If we look at guster girl's and catnapper's post they address the same issues but they put in their personal experiences as an example as to why one might reconsider or at least examine their reasons for adopting a kitten, especially one so old.
Quote:
Originally posted by PayItForward
Yes, we should question those who reject a 24 week old baby cat because they want an 12 week old baby cat.
And in 12 weeks what will they have ....GASP....a 24 week old baby cat, just what they didn't want !!!
Doesn't this sound familar !!!!! [/B]
Is there something wrong with wanting to adopt a younger cat? Yes, the difference between 12 weeks and 24 weeks is minimal but there is nothing wrong with wanting a kitten that young. The younger they are, the more dependent they are on you. And maybe that is what she is looking for?
I know I am opening myself up to a lot of flak but I believe there is a way to educate and question without the holier than thou attitude