American Idol Thread!

Printable View

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

03-31-2005, 12:43 PM
aly

I really didn't care for Jessica. She could sing, but she was very boring and not likable at all. I would take Mikalah over her any day! My favorites are Carrie, Nadia, Nikko, and Vonzell. I didn't like Vonzell initially, but she has been awesome lately! I REALLY loved her last week when she sang 'Best of My Love'. She really came alive and had fun. Carrie would be an awesome pop/country singer. Nikko and Nadia are really entertaining for me to watch as well. Even when Nadia did that Cindi Lauper song with the mohawk that the judged hated, I loved it.

Time for Anthony or Constantine to GO! Constantine really freaks me out. I hate how he looks at the camera, yikes!
03-31-2005, 01:02 PM
RobiLee

Aly, I can't believe you said that! Mikalah :eek: . Oh gosh, I can't stand her...lol. I liked her in the beginning because I thought she was funny, but now she is down right annoying and she can't sing at all! I really like Nadia. I think she is a true performer. She just seems to have the all around package.
03-31-2005, 01:04 PM
jazzcat

Anthony so needs to go. He's like listening to fingernails on a chalkboard to me. His voice is in a range I can't stand so he sounds out of tune the whole time he sings. Same with Anwar. I loved him at first but he's been bad lately. That guy Scott - the gangster wanna be - can leave too.

Carrie can sing, but I think she has major attitude and sounds too country. She belongs on Nashville Star, not American Idol.

I hope Bo wins.
03-31-2005, 02:01 PM
ILoveMyAbbyGirl

Bo and Constantine!

:D:D:D:D
03-31-2005, 02:01 PM
petslover

What has Carrie done to have an attitude? I hadn't see that side of her.
03-31-2005, 02:03 PM
Samantha Puppy

Quote:

Originally posted by petslover
What has Carrie done to have an attitude? I hadn't see that side of her.

Me either. I'm hoping she'll win. A top three with her, Bo and Nadia would be awesome.
03-31-2005, 02:21 PM
aly

Quote:

Originally posted by RobiLee
Aly, I can't believe you said that! Mikalah :eek: . Oh gosh, I can't stand her...lol. I liked her in the beginning because I thought she was funny, but now she is down right annoying and she can't sing at all! I really like Nadia. I think she is a true performer. She just seems to have the all around package.

Hehe, you're right she can't sing too well. But she was so entertaining. I think she'd be a great actress. She should go on Fran Drescher's new show and play her daughter!

Lori - I SO agree with what you said about Anthony. My boyfriend and I cover our ears when he sings.
03-31-2005, 02:48 PM
jazzcat

Quote:

Originally posted by petslover
What has Carrie done to have an attitude? I hadn't see that side of her.

Just the way she comes across to me. It's not fair to judge her like that but there is just something about her I can't put my finger on. It seems like I can see her ego inflate with every praise from the judges. My husband says it's because she has thin lips. He says I think every female with thin lips has attitude - guess I have a problem.:p

Anyway, I do think she can sing I just don't like country music much and I feel she's in the wrong contest.

Aly - glad to know I'm not the only one who feels that way about Anthony. Hubby kind of likes him because he reminds him of Dennis DeYoung from the band Styx.:rolleyes:
03-31-2005, 02:53 PM
pitc9

When Anthony sings... that's when I let the dogs outside so I don't have to hear him (try to) sing. :p :D :p

Nadia is a good performer, but she is not all that good of a singer. I'm sure she won't be around for very long, she's been in the bottom three for the past few weeks!

I guess I'll be voting for Nikko now since Jessica is gone....:( :(

Aly... you make me laugh!! Mikalah over Jessica?!?
I'd take William Hung over Mikalah!!
:D :D
03-31-2005, 03:44 PM
aly

Quote:

Originally posted by pitc9

Aly... you make me laugh!! Mikalah over Jessica?!?
I'd take William Hung over Mikalah!!
:D :D

Well.. if you really want to laugh, I'll tell you I BAWLED like a big fat baby when Mikalah left the show. She was just always so cheerful and took criticism from Simon very well. Then her little farewell tape was so sweet. She's likable to me as a person. I do think she should be on the Starlet though and not American Idol. She'd be a much better actress. I knew she was going to leave last week though, so I voted for her 30 times! HAH! ;)
03-31-2005, 07:25 PM
Toby's my baby

I didnt care to much for Mikalah either, girls that sing country, (sorry, I am a country fan) I also really like the girl that usually wears her hair currly, and she looks like the girl off of American Dreams, anyways, thats who I want to win ;)
03-31-2005, 08:07 PM
pitc9

Quote:

Originally posted by aly
Well.. if you really want to laugh, I'll tell you I BAWLED like a big fat baby when Mikalah left the show.

I can't laugh... I know I cried last season when someone I loved got kicked off early... I can't remember who it was, but I know I cried too!! :o :D

Quote:

She was just always so cheerful and took criticism from Simon very well.

VERY true!! I thought the funniest thing she said to him once was that if she got kicked off, he had to go to her prom with her!
03-31-2005, 11:48 PM
krazyaboutkatz

This is the first American Idol that I've watched faithfully from the beginning and I'm really enjoying it.:D I think that they'll all very talented but my favorites are Bo, Constatine, Nadia, and Carrie.:D
04-01-2005, 10:26 AM
aly

Hey, did you guys hear about Scott? He has been arrested before for domestic violence .. but he accepted a plea and they reduced the charge to disorderly conduct, which is a misdemeanor.

The Idol producers aren't going to kick him off the show (like they did in the past with Frenchie and Corey). The producers said since Scott was up front about it and regretted it... and since it was a misdemeanor, that he could stay on the show. Corey was not up front about it initially.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive...l_scott_1.html

Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page