Can you tell your cats apart by just the feel of their fur?

I voted "yes", although I only have one cat right now (we're working on Daddy about that ;) ). But, when Mimi was still here, it was very obvious "who was who", as Mimi had really long hair and Butter's hair is quite short.

Logan

Yup, all of them have vastly different fur, excpet my first two. Allen and Pouncer have what I call "typical cat fur" - about 80% of the cats in the rescue feel just like them. I can usually tell one from the other based on their body response to my touch though :p

Harry has very bristly fur. Its rough and not the nicest fur to pet, which is llucky since he hates being petted.

Abby has fur like satin. I could pet her all day, which is lucky because she'd love to be petted all day (well not right now since she's still running from me :()

Flutter feels like a bunny rabbit :)

I can tell my Meezers from the Non Meezers as the Meezer Furs a lot softer.
I was having trouble telling Michael and Miquelito apart, but now Miquelito is getting bigger, and Micheal is shrinking.
Princess has a mmrreeeeooow when I pet her, and Precious has a motor boat rumble purr.
The softest Cat is JJJ3 whos like silk.

Yep! :)
Zippy's fur is softer then Pumpkins

Stormie's hair is softer and a little bit longer than Aza's

By fur alone, I can tell Macduff's (medium long and rather course), B.L. (long and silky), Taranis (basic short hair but with mats that cause me to get bitten daily as I try to deal with them), Surya (short and a bit sparse and dry), Belle (medium long and silky but with a tendency to clump in places), Cattulus (incredibly soft and with very loose skin), Darcy (also incredibly soft but less loose skin), Nougat (Siamese, soft and very dense), Ginger (my very old lady whose fur feels like an old lady's), Dude (rather course and rough to go with his life). The rest are all short hair and I would probably get a few of them mixed up so it would be body size that would tell me if I was touching Luke or LOS, Dagda or Maeve, Tom or Pete, Thumper, Ashley or Raven.

We should have another thread/poll to see who can tell which cat jumped on the bed in the dark.

Oh yes!!!!
Maya has short and very thick fur, semi-soft.

Inka has long silky fur, very widdle

Zazou has such soft long fur, never has any tangled hair

Snoopy has very short coarse fur

Absolutely Donna, each cat i have is completely different, Ash although short haired has incredibly thick fur,Ellie-Mae is more coarser, her daughter Nikki has the most beautiful fur of them all , i call her my velveteen Rabbit because is almost as soft as a rabbits,well close, and Lexie's is different again, not sure how to describe hers really, and as i am still allergic to my furbabies,some cats fur affect me more than others, i think Ash is probably the worst. :)

Zam has very soft fur while Logan's is a bit more corse. Same with Kia and Chipper. Kia = soft; Chipper = corse. :D

Of course with my babies.. I know for sure by the feel of their hair..

Very definitely. Mishi's is long and silky. Mitzi's is very plush and coarse.

Yep!

Does it have short hair? then it's either Cami, Bear, or Dusty.
Does it have ears & tail?? if not then it's Dusty, if yes proceed on
Does it have a large head, and flabby belly? if yes it's Bear if not it's Cami

Does it have medium hair? Then it's either Jack or Pooky
Does it have a fat tail? if yes and it growls when you pet the tail then it's Jack, if not then it's Pooky.

If/When ever the kittens get full roam of the house I'll have to wait a bit to see if I can identify them in the dark or not.

As for specifically just fur..

Pooky has very silky rabbit like fur,
Jack has soft but coarser fur than Pooky
Bear has short but thick fur
Cami has short but silky fur
Dusty has old kitty fur kinda coarse.

Mine are both shorthairs, but:

Don Juan has a coarse outer coat and soft fluffy undercoat.
Zerlina's hair is short, smooth and incredibly silky.

:D

Liz

Yes I can with my five big cats but I have a feeling it may get harder once Moxie and Decker are grown. I think Moxie's fur will feel a lot like Jazz.

Yes, because Tiger's tail was broken when he was dumped on the highway with another cat. :( it's healed now but with a kink on it.