Printable View
Chicken Soup can be good for many dogs, for some it's too rich. It does have good ingredients, and if it's readily available you might as well try it! Canidae is one of my favorites, still, because it is generally great for dogs of all ages/sizes, very affordable (cheaper than Chicken Soup) and it has high quality ingredients.
I do not recommend Authority, as they use corn in all of their formulas (except maybe the Harvest Baked?). Wellness has also been going down hill since the new formula.
:) I have a question, why is Iams so bad? I have seen so many replys that are being negative towards Iams. Sorry I won't switch to it just wanna know!!
Alrighty then.. thanks! I'm going to try the olive oil, or the raw eggs... thanks! :)
It all lies in Iam's ingredient list. A lot of people hate Iams because of PETA's propaganda, but, honestly, I really could not care less about that. :oQuote:
Originally Posted by Flatcoatluver
Let's do a quickie ingredient analysis:
Okay, so chicken happens to be the first ingredient. However, corn meal and ground whole grain sorghum (used to make alcoholic beverages) follow thereafter. Chances are the quantity of grain products is equal to or even more than the quantity of chicken.Quote:
Chicken, Corn Meal, Ground Whole Grain Sorghum, Chicken By-Product Meal, Chicken Fat (Preserved with mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Dried Beet Pulp (Sugar Removed), Natural Chicken Flavor, Fish Meal, Potassium Chloride, Dried Egg Product, Brewers Dried Yeast, Salt, Flax Meal, Calcium Carbonate, Sodium Hexametaphosphate, Fish Oil (Preserved with mixed Tocopherols, a source of Vitamin E), Choline Chloride, Minerals (Ferrous Sulfate, Zinc Oxide, Manganese Sulfate, Copper Sulfate, Manganous Oxide, Potassium Iodide, Cobalt Carbonate), Vitamins (Vitamin E Supplement, Ascorbic Acid, Vitamin A Acetate, Calcium Pantothenate, Biotin, Thiamine Mononitrate (Source of Vitamin B1), Vitamin B12 Supplement, Niacin, Riboflavin Supplement (Source of Vitamin B2), Inositol, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Source of Vitamin B6), Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid), DL-Methionine, Rosemary Extract
Chicken by-products include feet, necks, blood, and other parts of the animal that are usually deficient in quality and nutrients. When you feed these parts fresh and whole, however, the story is entirely different.
Natural Chicken Flavor - A dog does not need artificial flavoring in his food.
Salt - A dog does not need added salt in his food. You don't see raw feeders seasoning their dog's food with salt or pepper :p
I also have qualms with dried beet pulp, but that's another controversy in itself. Hope this helps you some!
Thank you so much, that helps me a lot. At the dog kennel I work for almost EVERY DOG OWNER feeds their dogs either Iams or Beniful(sp?). I know Beniful is really bad.Quote:
Originally Posted by Giselle
What else about Iams... your dog is being subject to a chloride overdose, which could be harmful. By products also includes feces and the litter used on the ground where the chickens were housed. For some reason aafco allows dehydrated garbage (roughage) as an ingredient but labels do not have to include non-digestable roughage, so perhaps Iams uses a lot of this. The grains left over from processing are spent to a point where there is nothing left but empty space. They could leave them out of the recipe altogether and the dog wouldn't lose any nutrients. Dried beet pulp is sugar, so I don't know whats left after they removed it. I'm sure the list goes on.
Dried beet pulp is not sugar - it is what is left after the sugar is extracted. It's just pulp, probably to add the reddish color, and some roughage. Um, and we all do need some roughage in our diet. Helps your digestive tract.Quote:
Originally Posted by IRescue452
How does Iams subject the dog to "chloride overdose?"
Please don't make blanket statements like that without giving proof.
Kay and Giselles list are what Id say. from theres I would pick Solid Gold or Wysong and maybe Natural Balance.
Chloride in dog food has recently been discovered to be bad there is not yet going to be a scientific peer-reviewed article on it. Its hard to find "proof" on anything in the dog food business. There's also no peer reviewed article that says raw prey food is best for carnivores, because scientists don't waste their time writing common sense and getting it reviewed, they won't get paid for that. Beet pulp is "the dried residue extracted from the processing of manufactured sugar. It contains pure sucrose, as in common white refined sugar. The fiber content of beet pulp is used as a filler and as a bunder to artificially create better formed stools" I suppose with the sucrose removed its just used to make you think the dog has good stool, therefore healthy.
Both are good foods, but I just wanted to add that Chicken Soup is cheaper than Canidae in my area, by about $7ish per large bag (40ish lbs) and can OFTEN be found on sale for even cheaper than that. Canidea however is rarely on sale in my area.Quote:
Originally Posted by bckrazy
I think just about any brand of kibble I would reccomend has already been listed.
Chloride (an ionic form of chlorine) cannot exist by itself Chlorine is a highly reactive chemical, and is not found alone. Sodium Chloride, AKA table salt, is a very common compound, as are calcium and potassium chloride. All are found in the food that a dog would eat naturally.
Scientists FREQUENTLY write "common sense" and put it up for peer review.
If there is any sucrose left in the sugar beet pulp it is a damned poor refining process. The dried reside is almost certanly pure fiber, which aids digestion.
As to Sorghum being used to make alcoholic beverages, here's a challenge......find me a grain that is NOT used for that purpose. If we avoided the grains used to make alcohol as part of our diet, we would not be eating wheat, corn, rice, rye, or any other grain. That statement is a red herring.
Should I be looking at feed stores for brands such as Canidae, Innova, etc?
Natural Balance is the Dick Van Patten food or whatnot, right?
All my Goldens are currently on Nutro Natural Choice Lamb & Rice and are doing very well, I have nice coats, skin, and stool. I am switching my little girl Hailey onto Solid Gold to see if I like it though... It's REALLY expensive though, in this area. I pay $27.00 for a 40lb bag of Nutro, and $26.00 for a 15lb bag of Solid Gold Wolf Cub.