Ailing Manson follower asks for early release due to terminal illness

http://www.cbc.ca/cp/world/080614/w061406A.html

Ailing Manson follower asks for early release due to terminal illness
Published: Saturday, June 14, 2008 | 1:17 AM ET
Canadian Press: Linda Deutsch, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

LOS ANGELES - Susan Atkins, the former Charles Manson follower who confessed to killing pregnant actress Sharon Tate during a murderous rampage in 1969, has a terminal illness and has asked for compassionate release from prison in her final days, authorities said Thursday.

Atkins, 60, who has been incarcerated at the California Institution for Women at Frontera for 37 years, has been held longer than any other female inmate in state history.

Department of Corrections spokeswoman Terry Thornton declined to specify the nature of her illness.

"She is very ill" and has been hospitalized, said Thornton.

"Her condition is very serious and her prognosis is poor," she said.

Thornton said a doctor determined that Atkins has less than six months to live, which could make the application for release futile because of the length of the process.

"Sometimes inmates being considered for compassionate release die during the process," Thornton said.

Atkins was the most notorious of the three women charged with Manson in the grisly slayings of Tate and six other people in the summer of 1969. She enabled authorities to break the case after it had remained unsolved for three months by confessing to a cellmate when she was arrested in an unrelated crime. It was Atkins who disclosed that the Manson Family, a rag tag cult living in a ranch commune, had been responsible for the murders.

Her statements led police to a Death Valley hideout where they found Manson and other members of his cult. Her lawyer later complained that prosecutors broke a promise to her of leniency for breaking the case.

In a sensational 10-month trial, Atkins, Manson and co-defendants Patricia Krenwinkel and Leslie Van Houten maintained their innocence. But once they were convicted, the women took the stand in the penalty phase and confessed in graphic detail to the killings.

Atkins calmly recounted her own role in stabbing the pregnant Tate, who pleaded for the life of her unborn baby.

In her chilling testimony, she said, "I don't know how many times I stabbed her and I don't know why I stabbed her.... She kept begging and pleading and begging and pleading and I got sick of listening to it, so I stabbed her."

She said the killings were done under the influence of hallucinogenic drugs.

"I was stoned, man, stoned on acid," she testified.

She expressed no remorse until years later when, at her parole hearings, she apologized. But she also suggested she may have exaggerated her role during the trial and that she did not actually kill Tate. The claim was dismissed by prosecutors as self-serving.

At the end of her trial testimony, she said, "I feel no guilt for what I've done. It was right then and I still believe it was right."

A psychiatrist who examined her at the time said she was mentally ill. Jurors heard about her troubled childhood and the trauma of losing her mother at a young age to cancer.

She and the others were sentenced to death but their terms were commuted to life in prison when the U.S. Supreme Court briefly outlawed the death penalty in the 1970s.

Atkins became a gray-haired matron who worked in various jobs at the prison including serving as a receptionist at the front desk. She said no one recognized her. She became a born-again Christian in prison and she married more than once. Her current husband, James Whitehouse, has been acting as her lawyer.

He did not immediately respond to an after hours call Friday seeking comment.

Thornton said the prison had given "a positive recommendation" for her compassionate release.

"Because of her failing health it is not likely she would be a danger to society," Thornton said.

She said the matter would next go to the State Board of Parole which has the power to release Atkins so she can die with loved ones, at their expense.

Such releases are relatively rare - only 10 of the 60 requests made last year were granted, Thornton said. The prisoners must have family members willing and able to care for them.

The matter could be referred to the sentencing court in Los Angeles, she said, which could delay the decision even further.

Los Angeles County district attorney's spokeswoman Sandi Gibbons said the office had not yet decided what position it would take on the request.
© The Canadian Press, 2008

Yes, I saw the interview yesterday on Yahoo. She probably isn't the same person as she was when she helped commit the murders. So? I don't recall a caveat to the prison sentence being "Now, if you change or if you become terminally ill, you shall be released immediately to die in comfort, unlike your helpless victims."

IMO, let's show her the same amount of "compassion" she showed her victim.

Having studied the Manson murders extensively, you have to wonder honestly why she was in prision at all. It was proven that A the woman was brainwashed using a combination of drugs and other techniques and B she was not in her right mind when the murders were committed. In this day and age that is enough of a reason to put a person in a mental hospital, not a prision.
Also further reasearch into the case suggests that she was told to confess to the murders by other members of the Manson cult so that the least ammount of people got into trouble for it. No one REALLY knows exactly what happened on the day the murders were committed. No person involved told the same story. Even according to the prosicuting attourney, the evidence used to convict Atkins was circumstantial at best, and that they never really did trust the person who said she confessed to the murder. Some people even suggesst that the person she "confessed" to in jail was only trying to get out of jail herself and fabricated parts of the story. Also, Atkins "confession" in the courtroom was made AFTER she was found guilty. I doubt anything she could have said in the punishment phase of her trial would have made any difference in the punishment she recieved. Who knows what she was told to say, or why she said what she did.
When this case was tried, people wanted answers and a scapegoat. A famous person (especially a pregnant famous person) being murdered is a huge deal and someone had to be blamed for it and quickly otherwise the whole thing would turn into a circus.
I'm not saying Atkins did anything right by any means, but it is unfair to have a "let her rot in prision" attitude especially when there are things about the case that remain unkown.
The Manson murder case is one of the most complecated murder cases in US history. I don't think there is anything about it that is clear cut or black and white.

Atkins herself said on the witness stand that she told Sharon Tate, when she asked for mercy, that she had no mercy for her. That sounds to me like she was pretty involved in the murders. If it had been my daughter that was murdered and I knew that Atkins had said that to her when she was pregnant and begging for mercy, I wouldn't want Atkins to be paroled.