Log in

View Full Version : Allentown Woman ordered out of "bubble"



jennielynn1970
10-20-2008, 05:50 PM
I had no idea this was even going on in Allentown, lol.

Story with picture of "bubble" (http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20081020/ap_on_re_us/steel_shed_allergy)

Pa. woman ordered out of chemical-free 'bubble'
By MICHAEL RUBINKAM, Associated Press Writer Michael Rubinkam, Associated Press Writer 31 mins ago

ALLENTOWN, Pa. – Ten hours a day, every day, Elizabeth Feudale-Bowes confines herself to a galvanized-steel-and-porcelain shed outside her house. Inside are a toilet, a metal cabinet, a box spring with the metal coils exposed, and a pile of organic cotton blankets. Aluminum foil covers the window. The place is as austere as a prison cell — but it's also her sanctuary from an outside world that she says makes her violently ill.

She and her husband call the structure "the bubble."

This bubble, though, may be about to burst: A judge has ordered it taken down by the end of the month.

Some of the couple's neighbors in suburban South Whitehall Township complained that the 160-square-foot building is unstable and so unsightly it could drag down their property values. The couple also hooked up electrical, water and sewer service without securing permits.

"For the wife's medical problems, there is sympathy. For the owner's defiance of the township's lawful directives, there is no excuse," Judge Carol McGinley ruled earlier this month.

Feudale-Bowes, 52, says she was diagnosed several years ago with "environmental illness," described as extreme sensitivity to everyday substances.

Some doctors question whether environmental illness is a genuine physical disorder and suggest it is psychological. Feudale-Bowles says she was diagnosed by Dr. William Rea of Texas, who has been accused by the Texas Medical Board of promoting "pseudoscience." He vigorously disputes the charge and continues to see patients.

Feudale-Bowes says fabric softener, nail polish, perfume, new sneakers, upholstery and many other items can make her body go haywire. She says she has suffered from a range of chronic ailments, including migraines, joint pain, bladder inflammation, seizures and temporary paralysis. Her insides, she says, have sometimes felt like "fire with ground glass in it."

A couple of years ago, the couple settled in South Whitehall, moving into a Lustron house, a 1940s-era prefabricated home made of porcelain-enameled steel that serves as their main residence. They paid an additional $10,500 for the bubble.

The zoning board has recommended the couple explore other options, such as an addition to their house.

"We're just asking them to comply with the same safety codes that every other person in the community has to comply with," said Township Manager Jerry Gasda.

The couple are threatening to sue the township under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.

"My wife's not a lawn mower, and I didn't put up an illegal shed just to mess with the township," said Craig Bowes, 52, who owns a company that cleans supermarket floors.

Some neighbors question whether her ailment is genuine. But they and others say the main issue is the couple's disregard of the zoning rules.

Thomas Kelly, 53, who lives across the street, said that while he feels sorry for Feudale-Bowes, her husband "just did whatever he pleased."

"We don't live like that," he said. "We live in a society governed by laws."

But Feudale-Bowes said: "If I don't live like this, my pain level is so severe that I can't function, I can't live, I can't survive. It's excruciating."

Catty1
10-20-2008, 06:28 PM
I can understand the husband and wife being defiant...but I think their attitude is less than helpful.

If they used this media chance to say, "An addition to the house is a great idea, but we just can't afford it.", they might have received all kinds of help. Including a second opinion from another doctor....

jennielynn1970
10-20-2008, 06:34 PM
I'm wondering what kind of history they have in the state they used to live in. Did they try the same thing there? Did they try to sue the city they lived in there as well?

When you move to a new place, you normally try to find out what is allowed, what isn't, what permits you need, and all that. You don't just move in and do whatever you want.

She has things wrapped in plastic bags. Are plastic bags made of chemicals??? I just don't see how she can actually be fine in her self made environment when she's got chemicals in there anyway. And "organic" cotton towels. Wow.

The doctor she went to initially sounds like a piece of work.

Karen
10-20-2008, 07:13 PM
I think that, for what it cost them to build the "bubble," they could have adapted a room or rooms in their actual home to be better. Good gracious, if she can spend the other 14 hours of the day inside the house ... why not adapt a room within to be better suited. To her needs?

I have many environmental allergies - cleaning products, pollen, dust, etc, and while I have often wished science could provide me with a "force field" to keep such things out, I know it's not possible. I, too, question her original diagnosis, and wonder how much is physical ad how much psychological - just on the basis of the other 14 hours of the day!

DJFyrewolf36
10-21-2008, 01:25 AM
Exactly what does she do for 14 hrs a day? If she really was that ill, why does she feel having to go OUTSIDE to get into the isolation structure is going to be in any way helpful?

It doesn't make a lot of sense to me, which tells me that there is probibly more to this story than whats in the news...it will be interesting to see updates!

Medusa
10-21-2008, 08:59 AM
I think that, for what it cost them to build the "bubble," they could have adapted a room or rooms in their actual home to be better. Good gracious, if she can spend the other 14 hours of the day inside the house ... why not adapt a room within to be better suited. To her needs?

I have many environmental allergies - cleaning products, pollen, dust, etc, and while I have often wished science could provide me with a "force field" to keep such things out, I know it's not possible. I, too, question her original diagnosis, and wonder how much is physical ad how much psychological - just on the basis of the other 14 hours of the day!

My thoughts exactly.

RICHARD
10-21-2008, 12:12 PM
I had a bunch of questions about this story.

My first thought was about the complaints.

I can see a neighbor asking Craig, "What ya doing?"
"Putting up a room for the old lady, she's sick and need to be shut off from
air..."
"Hmmmmmm...."

So he goes home and tell his wife what good old Craig is up to.
"Seems like the neighbor has some kind of illness where she has to be cooped up, like in isolation!"

She mentions this at the bridge club - "The woman next door has some kind of illness-she has to be put into quarantine, her husband is building a room where she can't spread her germs!"

People start to take walks by the property to see this isolation room and start to wonder about exactly what this woman has and why! This freaks people out and they start to get scared-WE COULD CATCH THIS!!!!

They manage to find a way to present it to the township and get the
zoning ordinance people to enforce the rules.

(next time you see a story like this remember the key phrase-property value!
I know people invest tons of money into property but sometimes that is the excuse for lodging a complaint against the tenant/owners.)
------------------

Yes, they should have not gone and added to the home without the proper permits, the doc was a kinda fruitcake that may be a little off his rocker, But
I think that the situation should have been given a little more scrutiny. Could that time given her a little relief from her problems-if they are true?

I do see both sides to this problem, but sometimes have to wonder about noisy neighbors that run the 'hood!

lizbud
10-21-2008, 05:04 PM
My thoughts exactly.


Mine too.:) They could have converted a "sterile space" inside the house.

Lady's Human
10-21-2008, 05:42 PM
The normal remedy for building without a permit, if all code issues are satisfied, is to pay for a permit and pay a fine for not getting the permit beforehand.

For the judge to order the structure torn down implies that there are serious safety code violations.

RICHARD
10-21-2008, 06:11 PM
The normal remedy for building without a permit, if all code issues are satisfied, is to pay for a permit and pay a fine for not getting the permit beforehand.

For the judge to order the structure torn down implies that there are serious safety code violations.

LOL,
If you ever come out to Cah Lee Fuh Nee Ah you'll see some places that would make the town MILLIONS in fines.

I worked as a handy man once and saw a washer drain into a septic tank with radiator hoses.

I had to do a double take on that one.:eek:

jennielynn1970
10-21-2008, 07:06 PM
I just don't understand why someone with "environmental" allergies would purposely move here. Allentown, Bethlehem, this whole area is known for allergies, and with all the industrial plants we had around here, and the pollution, WHY would you move here??? She lives by a town with a cement factory that smells like sulfur for goodness sake.

Although she could have moved to Freemansburg (about 15 mins. away) next to the sanitation waste facility that smells like, well, exactly what it sanitizes!


It's just ridiculous.

shepgirl
10-21-2008, 07:18 PM
My thoughts exactly.

Mine also....I agree that and addition or spare room with air purifiers would have done the same thing.
I think the neighbors read through the whole psychological game here.

shais_mom
10-21-2008, 08:39 PM
I read the article but can't get the link to work for the picture.
interesting -
they sound awfully defiant. :(

sparks19
10-21-2008, 08:50 PM
and when she opens the door to get in doesn't she allow all the things that set her off anyway?