Is he really an Idol??? Scary...:<

[Kfamr]

Personally, I think Ruben has WAY more talent than "Clay".

[CamCamPup33]

Exactly.. I think Clay sounds like a Old, Country singer who is a girl.... Ruben had alot more talent.. hehe i still remember when we were watching it and were like "ok they are gonna say it! YES ROOOO BEN WON!"

[Twisterdog]

Originally posted by Shelteez2
I think people may be reading more into this than was meant.



Personally I interpret this to mean he was traumatized by running over his cat. No where did he say that he hated the kitten and so chose to run it over for fun because that's what cats deserve. Don't put words into people's mouths.

Oh and I'm not a Clay Aiken fan. I'm not even an "Idol" fan I think it's a dumb show.

I do know that I don't trust PETA though.

I don't have the faintest idea who Clay Aiken is. And I don't care. Yes, I think he probably should have thought a little more before he opened his mouth about this, but lots of people (myself included!) tend to ramble off at the mouth, without fully thinking through the reaction our words will bring. Remember when Pres. Bush - the first one - got in trouble for saying he didn't like broccoli?

However, I certainly have to agree with Shelteez about PETA. Basically, if it is on PETA website, I'm going to take it with a grain of salt and assume it is either exaggrated, taken out of context, or a flat-out lie. PETA is far, far more dangerous than some flash-in-pan star is ever going to be.

[CamCamPup33]

Originally posted by green_chameleon_girl
Clay is Gay
Dont let him play
with your kittens or cats
he will hit them with bats.
Then I will skin him alive
and he will die

ehhh.. nice?

[bluekat]

Originally posted by CamCamPup33
Exactly.. I think Clay sounds like a Old, Country singer who is a girl.... Ruben had alot more talent.. hehe i still remember when we were watching it and were like "ok they are gonna say it! YES ROOOO BEN WON!"

Too true He does look kinda like a girl He is a country singer, lol. and he's even got the accent

[Kfamr]

Originally posted by green_chameleon_girl
this is my poem Its rude I know but its totally the truth!


Clay is Gay
Dont let him play
with your kittens or cats
he will hit them with bats.
Then I will skin him alive
and he will die

Uhh... Ok?

[carole]

I must say I am somewhat disappointed to read this about Clay, as I did prefer him to win IDOL, however I was more than happy for RUEBEN to win .

If this is how he really is, then I no longer have the time of day for him, anyone who hates animals in any way, just does not enter my thoughts period.

This is indeed a shame if what was quoted is correct, because Clay is famous and famous people carry some clout, that is why its ok for them to have dislikes and likes sure, but they have to be ever so careful just who they tell, they influence a lot of people.

Staci has some good points, and I am in agreement with her on this one for sure.

[moosmom]

Wow. I knew there was something about him that I didn't like!

Ditto.

He's an idiot. Everytime he opens his mouth, he looks stupid, not to mention his looks in general.

I voted for the other guy. Anyone who says that about cats is a jerk. Especially when he says it in public.

STUPID, STUPID PEOPLE...INCLUDING CLAY AIKEN!!!

[CathyBogart]

Uh huh....interesting.

Not the kind of think an intelligent person would say in public, but I don't dislike him for hating cats...I just find him dislikable.

[Uabassoon]

Clay is Gay
Dont let him play
with your kittens or cats
he will hit them with bats.
Then I will skin him alive
and he will die

How come when people don't like something it's automatically "gay"?

[Kater]

That is not an appropriate use of the word gay. It is very disrespectful.

[Shelteez2]

Originally posted by green_chameleon_girl
this is my poem Its rude I know but its totally the truth!

It is huh?? Pretty serious accustations you're making.
And I was unaware that he made his sexual preferences public. Unless of course you mean he's happy. But I don't think so.

[G.P.girl]

Originally posted by Uabassoon
How come when people don't like something it's automatically "gay"?

i was wondering the same thing.
but i love clay and i think he run voer thcat by accident and is haunted by that. anybody would be. maybe he didn't have exactly the right choice of words to say that, but he is entitled to his own opinion even if he is a celebrity.

[lovemyshiba]

What a rude poem!!!
Highly offensive.


Anyway, I never liked Clay Aiken to begin with, and this gives me even more of a reason. I take things from Peta with a grain of salt also, but Staci did post more sources than the Peta website.

He's an idiot.

[Twisterdog]

Originally posted by green_chameleon_girl
this is my poem Its rude I know but its totally the truth!


Clay is Gay
Dont let him play
with your kittens or cats
he will hit them with bats.
Then I will skin him alive
and he will die

Ok ... let's see if have this correct ....

You are bashing someone that doesn't like cats .... by comparing him to someone who is homosexual?

And you are upset with someone who said they ran over a cat ... so you are saying you will skin him alive and kill him? (Obviously, I know you don't mean literally.)

To say your poem is "rude" is putting mildly.

Homophobia has no place here, or anywhere else, IMO.