To neuter or not?

[ESS-lover]

In general I am FOR neutering. We have chosen not to neuter Cowboy until he completes field training and we see how he does at a few trials. Cowboy is a Champion bred field ESS - who if he lives up to his potential will be one of the ones that people will want to breed with... However, our vet keeps pushing us to neuter him.

I am torn -- he is an incredible dog with high prey drive, a fabulous nose, and relentless hunter... and working field bred are much harder to find than show bred.

Is it wrong to wait and see if he should be bred or should we just go ahead and snip him?

[Flatcoatluver]

welll you are going to end up with tons of behavior problem my baby english setter has excellent field lines like you but we bneutered him because he hd a terrible behavior problem.

[lute]

the only way i would breed any dog is if they were up to the breed standard and could do what they were origonally bred to do. Gracie got to pull a sled for the first time a week ago. she loved it. she's also a very nice sibe. i will POSSIBLY breed her, ONLY if she finishes her Championship in conformation.

[JenBKR]

welll you are going to end up with tons of behavior problem my baby english setter has excellent field lines like you but we bneutered him because he hd a terrible behavior problem.

I'll second that! Roscoe wasn't neutered until he was a little over 3 years old, and now he thinks he's king of the castle! We're working on it...

[Jessika]

welll you are going to end up with tons of behavior problem my baby english setter has excellent field lines like you but we bneutered him because he hd a terrible behavior problem.

Neutering doesn't really change a dog's behavior, good training does. The only thing neutering does really in terms of behavior is curb their want to roam if there is a female in heat in the area, or curb behaviors related to mating, not other behavorial problems.

[JenBKR]

Actually (according to my trainer) neutering before the age of three is a big deal for behavior. She said that since he was neutered so late, he is considered intact and it boosts his alpha personality. It also makes him want to mark EVERYWHERE :rolleyes:

[buttercup132]

thunder isnt nutered and hes the best dog ive had no behavoir problems, but i think we just got super lucky with him and no we never did or plan to breed him

[Tollers-n-Dobes]

Actually (according to my trainer) neutering before the age of three is a big deal for behavior. She said that since he was neutered so late, he is considered intact and it boosts his alpha personality. It also makes him want to mark EVERYWHERE :rolleyes:


Everyone has different opinions on this but I personally think it depends on each individual dog, Winston (Doberman) was just neutered this past year and he's about 8 or so. He's got to be one of the most laid back dogs ever, he rarely marks anywhere and has never even bothered to try becoming alpha with any dog or human. Apparently he was like this before he was neutered aswell though. :)

[AllAmericanPUP]

alot depends.
Did the breeder you got him from field test her/his dogs and hunt with them? were the dogs health tested for hips and elbows and thyroid, etc. etc. ?
considering he's field bred i know he wont meat the show standard so that doesnt even matter.

what matters is titling him in field tests AND getting him health tested before you even think about breeding him. to responsibly breed a dog you need to know the dog is the TOTAL package not just have the package, sure the dog can hunt but is he free of genetic health problems such as hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, thyroid problems, etc. etc. look into OFA if you havent already and look into any other health problems ESS's are known to have and get him tested for those too.

it costs alot of money to RESPONSIBLY breed a dog, sure anyone can throw two dogs together and exchange a stud fee or pick of the litter but that is NOT doing any dog or breed a favor and just ads to the overpopulation and disease riddled dogs out there.

[JenBKR]

Sorry, didn't mean to imply that this is the case for all dogs! It is a chance you have to take though in waiting (not to mention the health risks).

Roscoe's situation is a little different though - I don't know his whole history with his previous owner :)

[ESS-lover]

alot depends.
Did the breeder you got him from field test her/his dogs and hunt with them? were the dogs health tested for hips and elbows and thyroid, etc. etc. ?
considering he's field bred i know he wont meat the show standard so that doesnt even matter.

what matters is titling him in field tests AND getting him health tested before you even think about breeding him. to responsibly breed a dog you need to know the dog is the TOTAL package not just have the package, sure the dog can hunt but is he free of genetic health problems such as hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia, thyroid problems, etc. etc. look into OFA if you havent already and look into any other health problems ESS's are known to have and get him tested for those too.

it costs alot of money to RESPONSIBLY breed a dog, sure anyone can throw two dogs together and exchange a stud fee or pick of the litter but that is NOT doing any dog or breed a favor and just ads to the overpopulation and disease riddled dogs out there.


Why I am even considering (not for the pup or fee) is the ability he has shown so far (still more training and field testing to come). His breeder has his parents and grandparents - all good/clear, etc on health tests - going back 4 generations all are healthy dogs and only 3 do not have FC to their credit....

Show conformation is out - he would fail miserably... LOL

[Love4BCs]

*sigh*

Neuter.

[Flatcoatluver]

t.j endeed up running away 4 times, once on my birthday(looking for gf i guess). when he was neutered, after he got neutered he has stayed home. Thats the bahavior problems i had.

[Jessika]

t.j endeed up running away 4 times, once on my birthday(looking for gf i guess). when he was neutered, after he got neutered he has stayed home. Thats the bahavior problems i had.

Those are mating-related. ;) Unneutered males have a tendacy to wander to fidn females in heat

[Flatcoatluver]

oh well! same thang for me!! lol, neutering is one of the best thing you can do for cowboy!

[.sarah]

Why I am even considering (not for the pup or fee) is the ability he has shown so far (still more training and field testing to come). His breeder has his parents and grandparents - all good/clear, etc on health tests - going back 4 generations all are healthy dogs and only 3 do not have FC to their credit....

Show conformation is out - he would fail miserably... LOL
Then if he does well in the field and is well behaved, and is negative for hip & elbow dysplasia and all other tests needed for ESSs, and if you want to breed him, then you have a good specimen. But only if you're going to do all of that.

[bckrazy]

I have no miffs with people breeding if they breed responsibly. It sounds like you're on the right track... but really, it will require tons of hard work trialing him, paying $100's to get him tested, and training with him. And that's only half of the work. Don't just stud him out to whoever will pay, make sure you get to know the bitch's owner, see paper-work proving that she is purebred, has great lineage, and is completely health tested. You should probably require field titles on the female, too. This will require countless hours of research and work on you and your family's part, but if you really truly believe he's going to better the breed definitely pursue what you want to. You should talk to his breeder too, it sounds like she/he would make a great mentor.

I think we need pics of this hawt boy ;)

[jesse_3]

I agree with bckrazy! With breeding RESPONSIBLY (which it sounds like you are going the right direction so far) and the pics of your boy!:D;)

Steph and the gang

[cloverfdx]

JMO Neuter :(.

[ESS-lover]

here's pics of Cowboy --- he is FIELD so does not look like a conformation springer -- lots of people think he's a Brittany

[.sarah]

Pretty boy! You finally posted big pictures!! :D

And oh my gosh, I just love his name!