PDA

View Full Version : Interesting theory on dog attacks



Pit Chick
02-23-2005, 02:13 PM
Baby swings may trigger dog attacks
Associated Press

NEW ORLEANS — Rocking your baby to sleep in a mechanical swing may trigger a deadly attack on the child by the family dog, a coroner warns.

ADVERTISEMENT

At least two such deaths have been documented in Maryland over a four-year period, Dr. Albert Y. Chu of the state's medical examiner's office said today at a meeting in New Orleans of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences.

The back-and-forth motion may activate the dog's instinct to chase prey, he said.

"Think about dogs chasing cars or tennis balls. They can't control their behavior — they just go," he said.

In 2003, a 2-week-old boy was dragged from his swing and killed by the family's pit bull in Baltimore after the baby's mother left him to answer the front door. In Edgemere, Md., in 1999, a 3-month-old boy was mauled to death as his parents slept in another room.

An Associated Press check of online news archives found at least one more death — that of an 18-day-old girl in Tampa, Fla., in 2000 after her mother left the room to warm a bottle for her — and at least two non-fatal attacks around the country in the past few years.

In one of those cases, in Summerville, S.C., in 2003, the dog lunged for the baby and bit her in front of the child's mother.

In 2000, Sabrina Williamson of Peru, Ind., had gone to the store while her husband napped in another room, about six feet away from 9-week-old Alex. She walked back in and found her husband wrestling their pit bull off the baby. They had had the dog eight years, since Alex's brother was 4.

"I think it could be a key factor. Our dog had never been mean towards a child before," she said in a telephone interview.

The baby's face was bitten and bloody, and his collarbone was broken and protruding from his shoulder, police said.

Dr. Marianne DiPadua of University Foggia in Italy said she is not convinced that the rocking movement sets off the dog. "It's true movement can trigger an attack," she said. But she noted that dogs have also attacked babies in cribs or beds.

Dr. Jane Sanders, a radiologist and a board member of the humane society in Jackson, Miss., said she planned to pass on the information to the shelter's director. Most dog attacks are by pets that have never been aggressive, she said.

Catherine Mills, a Marshall, N.C., dog trainer with 25 years' experience, and John C. Wright, an animal behiavorist at Mercer University, said pets should be conditioned to ignore baby swings before a baby is put into one.

"Put the swing up, leave it on without a baby in it until the dog or cat totally ignores it," Mills said.

Wright suggested even more extensive "desensitization": Get the dog used to a lifelike crying doll — with a real diaper, if one is available — then the swing, then the two together.

Everyone interviewed agreed on one thing: Do not leave even the most trusted pet alone with a baby.

RICHARD
02-24-2005, 12:57 PM
Like could it be that freaking obnoxious 'clickety clack' noise those things make???

I wanted to bite my nieces and nephews after a few minutes of that noise....:mad: :eek: :confused:

lizbud
02-24-2005, 05:35 PM
It's a pretty far stretch to extrapolate dog behavior from
cause of death in humans. It's a theory I don't believe.

I'd look to the family situation the dog is in. I used a baby swing
for my children & never had that problem.

Suki Wingy
02-24-2005, 06:53 PM
they only specify the breed when it was "pit bulls":( My little sister slept in one of those all the time when she was young and Nino never did a thing.

Oggyflute
02-25-2005, 12:17 AM
scare sensationalism of the ignorant. :rolleyes:

Pit Chick
02-25-2005, 02:53 PM
Maybe it doesn't apply to all dogs, but there are probably some that get freaked out over a baby swing. My Ginger will bark and lunge and then run from the broom, so you never know what will set off a dog unless you really know your dog. Ginger would never attack the person holding the broom, she mostly reacts because she's being silly or just has some issue with the "monster" broom. There are several factors behind dog attacks and for some dogs a baby swing could be one.

RICHARD
02-25-2005, 03:01 PM
Originally posted by Pit Chick
Maybe it doesn't apply to all dogs, but there are probably some that get freaked out over a baby swing. My Ginger will bark and lunge and then run from the broom, so you never know what will set off a dog unless you really know your dog.


Probably because it doesn't like the baby swinging on the broom....:confused:

Twisterdog
02-26-2005, 07:57 PM
I don't buy that at all.

Ok, I'm sure somewhere in America, there IS probably a dog that went balistic from looking at a baby swing. There is, I'm sure, also a dog in America that attacked a box of tissues, a carrot or a throw pillow.

IMO, there is something very wrong with a family pet that would attack a baby, simply because it is a swing. Attempting to justify it as "prey drive" is absurd.

In what percentage of households with children and dogs do the children swing in baby swings or later in the backyard or playground swing, while the dog is watching? I'd venture to say close to 100%, at some time. What percentage of those dogs flipped out? .0000001%?

Pit Chick
02-28-2005, 02:50 PM
Originally posted by RICHARD
Probably because it doesn't like the baby swinging on the broom....:confused:

Dork. :p :D :rolleyes:

RICHARD
02-28-2005, 04:41 PM
Originally posted by Pit Chick
Dork. :p :D :rolleyes:

just exploring every possibility.:confused: :o

cali
03-01-2005, 06:32 PM
they only specify the breed when it was "pit bulls"

I noticed that too, if it was pitti then it was a "pit bull" if it was another breed it was a "dog" how much ya wanna bet those "dogs" were labs or goldens or something lol

Vette
03-04-2005, 07:21 PM
Thats just so stupid.. they say anything to bash a breed. :rolleyes:

if that was true id be dead. my parents had me in a baby swing,, and they had two Dobermans who never thought i was juicy piece of stake in my baby swing.